HDMI ARC vs Optical: Which Sounds Better?

For regular stereo and standard 5.1 Dolby Digital, HDMI ARC and optical sound the same. Both carry the same digital audio without loss for those formats.

HDMI ARC wins on features: one remote controls the TV and soundbar, it can carry Dolby Digital Plus (including the Dolby Atmos version most streaming apps use), and setup is simpler. HDMI eARC goes further and carries lossless Dolby TrueHD, DTS:X and full Dolby Atmos.

Optical wins on reliability with older gear. It has no handshake problems and works with almost every TV and receiver made since the 2000s.

HDMI ARC vs eARC vs Optical Compared

FeatureOptical (TOSLINK)HDMI ARCHDMI eARC
Stereo PCMYesYesYes
Dolby Digital 5.1 / DTS 5.1YesYesYes
Dolby Digital Plus (incl. streaming Atmos)NoYesYes
Lossless Dolby TrueHD / DTS-HD MANoNoYes
Full Dolby Atmos / DTS:XNoLimited (compressed Atmos via DD+)Yes
Multichannel uncompressed PCM (5.1/7.1)NoNoYes
Control with TV remote (CEC)NoYesYes
Lip-sync correctionManualOptional, varies by deviceBuilt into the standard
Interference immunityExcellent (light, not electrical)GoodGood
Common problemsFewCEC and handshake issuesNeeds eARC on both devices

How Each Connection Works

Optical

Optical sends audio as pulses of light through a fiber cable. Because it’s light, it’s immune to electrical interference and ground loop hum. The trade-off is bandwidth: optical was designed in the 1980s and can only carry stereo PCM or compressed 5.1.

HDMI ARC

ARC (Audio Return Channel) lets the TV send audio “back” down the same HDMI cable to your soundbar or receiver. It also uses HDMI-CEC, so your TV remote controls volume and power. Learn more in our HDMI-CEC guide.

HDMI eARC

eARC (enhanced ARC) arrived with HDMI 2.1-era TVs. It has far more bandwidth, so it can pass lossless and object-based formats. Both the TV and soundbar or receiver must support eARC to use it. See ARC vs eARC for the full breakdown.

Which Should You Use?

Your situationBest choice
Soundbar and TV both have eARCHDMI eARC
Soundbar and TV have ARC, you stream Netflix/Disney+ in AtmosHDMI ARC
You want one remote for everythingHDMI ARC/eARC
Older receiver without HDMI ARCOptical
ARC keeps dropping or losing soundOptical as a reliable backup
You hear a hum or buzz with HDMIOptical (no electrical connection)
You watch mostly cable TV in 5.1Either; they sound the same

When Optical Is the Better Choice

  • Older receivers that predate ARC
  • Unstable ARC setups that drop audio or don’t wake up with the TV
  • Ground loop hum between the TV and audio system
  • Simple stereo or 5.1 needs where you don’t care about Atmos

If your receiver has no ARC, our guide on how to connect a TV to a receiver without HDMI walks through optical, coax and analog setups.

When HDMI ARC Is the Better Choice

  • Streaming Dolby Atmos from apps that use Dolby Digital Plus
  • Convenience: one remote, auto power-on, volume on the TV screen
  • Cleaner setup: one cable you probably already have
  • Newer soundbars, many of which drop optical input or limit features over it

Setting it up for the first time? See how to connect a soundbar with HDMI ARC.

Does the Cable Matter?

  • Optical: any decent cable works. Avoid sharp bends and lengths over about 30 feet.
  • HDMI ARC: a standard High Speed HDMI cable is fine.
  • HDMI eARC: use an Ultra High Speed or High Speed with Ethernet cable for best results.

You don’t need expensive cables for audio. Our do HDMI cables make a difference guide explains why.

Common Problems and Fixes

ProblemLikely fix
No sound over ARCTurn on HDMI-CEC on the TV, use the port labeled ARC, set TV output to “Receiver/HDMI”
ARC sound cuts outUpdate TV and soundbar firmware, try another HDMI cable, power-cycle both
No sound over opticalSet TV audio output to optical, try PCM format
Only stereo over opticalSet digital audio to Bitstream/Auto; some apps’ formats can’t go over optical
Picture and sound out of syncAdjust audio delay on the TV or soundbar

More fixes are in HDMI ARC not working and HDMI handshake issue.

Real-World Example

Picture a household with a mid-range Atmos soundbar and a 2021 TV, connected by optical because “it just worked.” They play an Atmos movie on Netflix and hear plain 5.1. Switching to HDMI ARC, turning on CEC and setting the TV’s digital audio to Auto brings the Atmos effects back. It also lets the TV remote control the soundbar volume, which ends the two-remote juggling.

FAQs

Can I use HDMI ARC and optical at the same time?

You can connect both, but only one will be active. Pick the input on the soundbar or receiver. Some people keep optical connected as a backup.

Does optical support Dolby Atmos at all?

No. Optical can’t carry Dolby Digital Plus or TrueHD, so you won’t get Atmos height effects over it.

Is there a sound quality difference for music?

Not for standard streaming music. Both pass stereo PCM. Differences come from the soundbar or DAC, not the cable.

My TV has eARC but my soundbar only has ARC. What do I get?

You get regular ARC features. The connection uses the highest version both devices support.

Why does my soundbar turn off when I switch TV inputs?

That’s usually CEC behavior. Look for HDMI-CEC or “Anynet+/SimpLink/Bravia Sync” settings on the TV and adjust auto power options.

Should I pick a soundbar with eARC in 2027?

Yes, if you watch Blu-rays or use apps with lossless audio. Our best soundbar with eARC guide lists strong options. If your TV is older, check connect a soundbar without HDMI before you buy.



Leave a Comment